Embeddedness Made Easy (Polanyi Meets Indexed?)

With inspiration from indexed, xkcd and WickedAnomie, I present Embeddedness Made Easy (or, Polanyi Made Simple):

Polanyi Made Simple
(Polanyi 1944, 1947 before you get all Wikipedia on me. Speaking of which, I would love to make that protest sign sometime, maybe for an Intelligent Design or anti-Climate Science kind of presentation. Or, you know, a commencement speech. Whatever trips your trigger.)

7 Responses to “Embeddedness Made Easy (Polanyi Meets Indexed?)”

  1. Anomie Says:

    Awesome. There should be a Sociology Made Simple book, with nothing but flow charts and Venn diagrams. It could be in cartoon, with little stick figure narrators or something.

    I dare you to make a ‘citation needed’ sign and hold it up at someone’s conference presentation at ASA. Though, for the benefit of your career, perhaps that should be done at a friend’s presentation :) .

  2. Dan Hirschman Says:

    Hm.. I think my friends are only doing roundtables this year… Although my old advisor might be giving a talk… She has a pretty excellent sense of humor – she very much liked the Voodoo doll for example.

    Maybe I could wear a Drek costume?

  3. Natalie K. Says:

    “Maybe I could wear a Drek costume?”

    Hey, I recognize that joke from a few weeks ago…

  4. Anomie Says:

    Haha, yes! That would be hilarious if you did that to your old adviser! You could do it while wearing one of the shirts from Drek’s store

  5. Source scarcity and sink scarcity « Dead Voles Says:

    [...] might find this interesting I’m going to poke him by suggesting that this is an example of embeddedness. Daly has a nice venn diagram too, but his has the economy (and, by extension, society) embedded in [...]

  6. Has Economic Sociology Won? « A (Budding) Sociologist’s Commonplace Book Says:

    [...] Has Economic Sociology Won? I wonder if one unanticipated outcome of the financial crisis and the rescue programs being implemented in the US, Britain* and elsewhere is the (perhaps temporary) victory of Economic Sociology. Ok, what could I mean by that? If Economic Sociology makes one claim, it’s Granovetter 1985 – economic action is embedded in social structure. But if Econ Soc makes two claims, the second is that the market economy has always been embedded in the social and political world, and only became disembedded ideologically, not practically (Polanyi 1944, 1947). [...]

  7. RetroSociology Quotes of the Day: Berle, “Power Without Property” « A (Budding) Sociologist’s Commonplace Book Says:

    [...] “interlocked” is a nice complement to Polanyi’s argument that economy is “embedded” in society. And perhaps if the two had met, Polanyi would have been able to come up with a [...]

Leave a Reply